Thursday, January 27, 2011

Musings: Burial Disturbances

A white moon, waning toward a wedge, was still bright enough to light our way as Koko, Pa`ele and I followed our shadows mauka this morning. Scorpion slithered his way toward twinkling Venus and cobweb clouds drifted across the entire sparkling scene, eventually burying Waialeale in a deep pile of swirling gray.

I’ve got a story in Honolulu Weekly this weekly about the way burials are being handled at historic Kawaiahao Church on Oahu, and how the situation is yet another chapter in the growing trend toward usurping the power of Island Burial Councils. I previously wrote about how that played out with Joe Brescia’s house at Naue and in regard to the Honolulu rail project.

Just for the heck of it, you might want to check out how the Star-Advertiser handled the story, which inexplicably ran in the business section. Their article was prompted by a press release from the church, which was prompted by my investigations into the issue. It’s a good example of how so much of what the supposedly objective, impartial mainstream media “reports” is spun by public relations efforts.

But fortunately we still have a few independent sources of news.

Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to cover everything in the article, like how former Gov. Linda Lingle, even as she was restricting funds elsewhere, signed off on a $1 million grant in aid for the church. The church was required to spend the money by June 30, 2010, but in August, after the funds had lapsed, asked for an extension, which was recommended by the State Historic Preservation Division — the same agency that approved the questionable treatment of the iwi. SHPD claimed the multipurpose room that the church wants to build will help the agency’s own mission by preserving archival records, even though those very same records were unable to identify the 69 iwi that have been dug up.

I also didn’t have room to report how Kamuela Kala`i viewed the iwi, which were wrapped in muslin and stored in baskets on shelves in the basement of the church:

To say it felt eerie to view the kupuna in lauhala baskets stacked on shelves is to put it lightly. It felt tremendously sad to see them in this state and even more troubling to see empty lauhala baskets right on the opposite side of the room - waiting to be filled with more iwi.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Burial Council rules were formulated to handle incidental iwi finds. For a known church cemetery, these should be handled primarily by the church.

Is there a win-win? In the end, the "pono" thing to do is to honor those dis-interred and for the church to be able to fulfill its mission by completing the building.

Besides, for most people, it's not of their "kuleana" to interfere. Let's see how it plays out.

Anonymous said...

OHA gave the church $1 million, not Lingle. You think OHA is pissed about their investment now? Hell yeah.

Joan Conrow said...

No, the state also gave the church $1 million.

Anonymous said...

The church got $2 million then? Auwe!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

Christianity has from its beginnings in Hawaii, subjugated Kanaka Maoli culture and this saga at Kawaihao is a continuance of that and is why the Kahu supports finishing the construction. It was Kawaihao that turned its back on Queen Liliuokalani after the overthrow despite her being a devout and active member of the church for years. It was the St. Andrew's Cathedral that welcomed her in during a time of unrest and turmoil in the Kingdom and when she needed her faith more than ever.

I have ancestors buried there, both marked and unmarked and I am concerned about the fate of them.

Anonymous said...

"I have ancestors buried there, both marked and unmarked and I am concerned about the fate of them."

They'll be moved and re-interred. You won't know the difference. It'll be fine.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 3:22 pm:

I won't know the difference? How the f*#k do you know that and what matters to me obviously is of no significance to you. Such paternalistic bull crap.

Anonymous said...

"I won't know the difference? How the f*#k do you know that and what matters to me obviously is of no significance to you. Such paternalistic bull crap"

Shut up, whitey.

Anonymous said...

Hold on to believing your ancestors spirit are hanging out with their bones.

Anonymous said...

"Hold on to believing your ancestors spirit are hanging out with their bones."

This is exactly my point. Christianity has no tolerance for religious beliefs other than its own. A lack of respect for Kanaka Maoli religious beliefs IS exactly the problem here.

"Shut up, whitey."

Huh? He Hawaii au!!!! Unmarked graves in Kawaiha'o are not likely to belong to "whitey's".

Anonymous said...

This is the first I have read of a "Kanaka Maoili" as a Religion ? Is this a fact that I missed....or perhaps something new ?

Anonymous said...

kanaka - read traditional Hawaiian religious beliefs.

Anonymous said...

Religious beliefs without a Religion ? Is that the concept ? Works for me.... however the concept of a religion might help your cause.